8/13/2026

Silent movies - Namakura Gatana

Not the first anime, but one of the earliest surviving Japanese animation films is the short I have brought along today. It's "Namakura Gatana" ("The Dull Sword")  from 1917.
 

The plot is told really quickly as the film only runs 4 minutes in the longest available version (there is a 5 minute version now).

A samurai is testing his sword for sharpness.


He goes to the swordsmith called "Dull Sword" where he even struggles to get his katana into the sheath. Not a very smart samurai.
 

On the way back, he decides to try it out on random people he meets (luckily he can't hurt them and gets his butt kicked instead) - first a blind man playing the flute (attacking a blind man from behind, shame on him) ...
 

... then a traveller who walks right over him after defeating him.


When he tries to get up leaning on the sword, it gets all bent which makes him 
so mad that he throws it away.


To an audience of today this looks like a very weird little film. Not just the idea of a samurai ready to use his sword on unsuspecting people is rather preposterous, but there's also a lot of comical eye rolling and the eyebrows go up and down.

Now, I said it more than once. This film is almost 110 years old.
According to a Reuters story about the find of this short and another one, US and European animation films were first shown in Japan around 1914.
I just don't get why there are always people trying to measure work from that time by modern standards.
Actually, I was surprised how smooth the animation is.
There were also people complaining that there isn't sound ...
Something I didn't know until now is that a standard practice in Japanese silent cinema was to have a "benshi" or film narrator which could be the reason that there are so few title cards. Who knows, maybe we're missing a hilarious exchange between the samurai and the swordsmith.

The film was thought to be lost, but in 2007 it was being sold at an antique market in Osaka together with another film. What a find!
You know how excited I can get about stories like this!


Sources and further reading:

1. Catherine Munroe Hotes: The Dull Sword 
(なまくら刀, 1917). On: Nishikata Film Review, March 13, 2017
2. National Film Archive of Japan: The Dull Sword. On: Japanese Animated Film Classics

No comments:

Post a Comment

If you like what you've read, if you have a question, additional information or if you simply want to say hello, please do! I love comments and would like to hear from you.
Comments are moderated, however, to protect from spammers and trolls, so they will be published after approval.