Buster Keaton a villain? The shock!
Welcome to The Frozen North from 1922.
First the plot (spoiler alert).
"Last stop" - Buster arrives via subway.
Passing the saloon, he sees a roulette set up and decides to stage a hold up using the cutout of an ammunition advertisement. A drunk trying to take the cutout's revolver thwarts Buster's plan and he "leaves" the saloon through the window.
When he comes home, he finds his wife kissing another man. After a very emotional reaction, he shoots both of them only to find that it's not his house or his wife.
At his real home, he's very cold towards the embrace of his wife. She screams which arouses the attention of a Mountie walking by. Then she hits the wall which makes a vase drop from a shelf onto her head. When the Mountie comes checking, Buster is faking a dance with his unconscious wife.
Then he spots the Mountie's wife and immediately jumps into action and into his white suit. Very nonchalantly he courts her, but the Mountie comes back, kicks him and takes his wife away in a sleigh.
Buster gets his friend Joe to pursue them, but with a sleigh whose dog team is made up of a retriever, a whippet, a boxer, a dalmation, and dachshunds their chances to catch up are zero. The dogs take off without the sleigh and they change to a hansom on runners followed by a police Harley-Davidson on runners for speeding.
They escape and make it to an igloo which is furnished like a living room, complete with a chaiselongue, table and wall decorations.
To go ice fishing, Joe uses snowshoes, but Buster doesn't have any, so he uses the guitars from the wall.
After fishing, he notices the Mountie's wife again and another attempt at seducing her everything ends in a big showdown.
The Mountie attacks Buster with a knife, but Buster's wife happens to come by the window, sees her villain of a husband and shoots him.
In dying, Buster pulls his Derringer, he aims at the Mountie ...
... and gets woken up by the janitor in a movie theater. It has all been a dream!
So, what would get Buster Keaton to make such a surreal little piece with himself as the bad guy?
You wouldn't be able to understand - as I wasn't - if you have never heard of William "Two-Gun Bill" S. Hart before - as I hadn't.
Hart was a successful Shakespearean actor before becoming a Western superstar in silent movies for about a decade. That explains why I don't know him, I hardly ever watch any Western movies, old or new.
Keaton had worked with Roscoe Arbuckle before going solo, and in the big scandal that ended Arbuckle's career, Hart made public statements about presuming his guilt without ever having met him.
Keaton owed his friend a lot regarding his film career and he thought him to be innocent.
This spoof is said to be a way to get back at Hart by copying his outfit and mannerisms, from the heroic poses (for example in his house while his wife has a vase falling on her head) to shedding tears.
As Keaton said: "But the main thing he did in his pictures that they [cowboys] didn't do in real life was cry. After about 1918 there was at least one scene in which Bill broke down and unashamedly let glycerine tears roll down his thin, leathery he-man cheeks."
Keaton believed that "what really got him ... was my kidding his crying. My guess is that he knew in his heart just how fake that was. Perhaps he did it just to prove that his fans would accept anything he did on the screen. Bill did not speak to me for two years after he saw that picture."
In fact, Hart was in this movie as well - he's the cutout!
I had watched the film first and then found out about the story behind it, so some of the gags surprised me because they didn't fit in with what I had seen from Buster so far, the little man against life.
For an audience familiar with Hart's movies, however, this must have been hilarious to see.
Hart was not the only one he copied, though. The Mountie's wife reminded of Theda Bara, also called "The Vamp", in one scene she sees Buster as an officer which is a gag on Erich von Stroheim (who is said to have thought it funny).
I enjoyed the surreal sight gags such as those in the pictures above, but admit I was a bit relieved to see that it all had been a dream because it made so much more sense to me.
My family could tell you that I have the weirdest dreams, whole stories which are usually lacking the ending. Maybe I should make silent shorts from them?
Sources and further reading:
1. Gabriella Oldham: Keaton's Silent Shorts : Beyond the Laughter. Carbondale, IL : Southern Illinois Univ. Pr., 1996, pp. 250 - 267
2. Walter Biggins: Buster Keaton #14: The Frozen North (1922). On: Quiet Bubble, December 6, 2015
Welcome to The Frozen North from 1922.
First the plot (spoiler alert).
"Last stop" - Buster arrives via subway.
Passing the saloon, he sees a roulette set up and decides to stage a hold up using the cutout of an ammunition advertisement. A drunk trying to take the cutout's revolver thwarts Buster's plan and he "leaves" the saloon through the window.
When he comes home, he finds his wife kissing another man. After a very emotional reaction, he shoots both of them only to find that it's not his house or his wife.
At his real home, he's very cold towards the embrace of his wife. She screams which arouses the attention of a Mountie walking by. Then she hits the wall which makes a vase drop from a shelf onto her head. When the Mountie comes checking, Buster is faking a dance with his unconscious wife.
Then he spots the Mountie's wife and immediately jumps into action and into his white suit. Very nonchalantly he courts her, but the Mountie comes back, kicks him and takes his wife away in a sleigh.
Buster gets his friend Joe to pursue them, but with a sleigh whose dog team is made up of a retriever, a whippet, a boxer, a dalmation, and dachshunds their chances to catch up are zero. The dogs take off without the sleigh and they change to a hansom on runners followed by a police Harley-Davidson on runners for speeding.
They escape and make it to an igloo which is furnished like a living room, complete with a chaiselongue, table and wall decorations.
To go ice fishing, Joe uses snowshoes, but Buster doesn't have any, so he uses the guitars from the wall.
After fishing, he notices the Mountie's wife again and another attempt at seducing her everything ends in a big showdown.
The Mountie attacks Buster with a knife, but Buster's wife happens to come by the window, sees her villain of a husband and shoots him.
In dying, Buster pulls his Derringer, he aims at the Mountie ...
... and gets woken up by the janitor in a movie theater. It has all been a dream!
So, what would get Buster Keaton to make such a surreal little piece with himself as the bad guy?
You wouldn't be able to understand - as I wasn't - if you have never heard of William "Two-Gun Bill" S. Hart before - as I hadn't.
Hart was a successful Shakespearean actor before becoming a Western superstar in silent movies for about a decade. That explains why I don't know him, I hardly ever watch any Western movies, old or new.
![]() |
| William S. Hart, public domain via Wikipedia |
Keaton had worked with Roscoe Arbuckle before going solo, and in the big scandal that ended Arbuckle's career, Hart made public statements about presuming his guilt without ever having met him.
Keaton owed his friend a lot regarding his film career and he thought him to be innocent.
This spoof is said to be a way to get back at Hart by copying his outfit and mannerisms, from the heroic poses (for example in his house while his wife has a vase falling on her head) to shedding tears.
As Keaton said: "But the main thing he did in his pictures that they [cowboys] didn't do in real life was cry. After about 1918 there was at least one scene in which Bill broke down and unashamedly let glycerine tears roll down his thin, leathery he-man cheeks."
Keaton believed that "what really got him ... was my kidding his crying. My guess is that he knew in his heart just how fake that was. Perhaps he did it just to prove that his fans would accept anything he did on the screen. Bill did not speak to me for two years after he saw that picture."
In fact, Hart was in this movie as well - he's the cutout!
![]() |
| Tears! The string on the hat is another Hart thing. |
I had watched the film first and then found out about the story behind it, so some of the gags surprised me because they didn't fit in with what I had seen from Buster so far, the little man against life.
For an audience familiar with Hart's movies, however, this must have been hilarious to see.
Hart was not the only one he copied, though. The Mountie's wife reminded of Theda Bara, also called "The Vamp", in one scene she sees Buster as an officer which is a gag on Erich von Stroheim (who is said to have thought it funny).
I enjoyed the surreal sight gags such as those in the pictures above, but admit I was a bit relieved to see that it all had been a dream because it made so much more sense to me.
My family could tell you that I have the weirdest dreams, whole stories which are usually lacking the ending. Maybe I should make silent shorts from them?
Sources and further reading:
1. Gabriella Oldham: Keaton's Silent Shorts : Beyond the Laughter. Carbondale, IL : Southern Illinois Univ. Pr., 1996, pp. 250 - 267
2. Walter Biggins: Buster Keaton #14: The Frozen North (1922). On: Quiet Bubble, December 6, 2015


























































