Two weeks ago we had a college football hero, last week Harold Lloyd, how about Harold Lloyd at college today?
Here's "The Freshman" from 1925.
![]() |
| Public domain via Wikipedia |
Today we have a proper plot. As Lloyd says in his autobiography, films like the "Lonesome Luke" ones are gag type comedies, films like "The Freshman" are character comedies which start more slowly and develop.
Harold Lamb is a young man excited for college. He copies a greeting - a little jig and a handshake -, the outfit, and the nickname "Speedy" from his favorite college movie, he has saved some money, he has high expectations about becoming a "college hero" like his movie idol.
On the train he meets Peggy, he gets interested in her crossword puzzle and they get along splendidly.
Once arrived in town, Harold falls right into the hands of the College Cad (no names, it's practically a tpye) for whom he's the perfect victim due to his desire to be popular in connection with his incredible naiveté.
The Cad shows him the "car assigned to him" which is in fact the dean's car and lures him on the stage where the dean is supposed to hold the opening speech by making him save a kitten from a height (if that wasn't enough already to hate the Cad, just wait, there's more to come), then tells him he has to make a speech during which Harold is laughed at by the whole assembly.
The Cad and his friends - male and female - cheer for Harold who thinks he's on the best way to be popular and invites the group for ice cream, but the Cad keeps inviting more people on the way to the ice cream parlor.
Look who follows them, too!
![]() |
| Again, legally bound. |
After spending a good deal of his savings like that, Harold has to downgrade in regards to his living quarters.
There he meets Peggy again who happens to be the landlady's daughter. Harold's shirt has been ripped up when the kitten climbed up it under his sweater and Peggy sews the button on for him. You see him secretly cutting off more buttons.
To up his game, Harold tries out for the football team, but the coach isn't impressed. When their only tackle dummy is damaged, however, they use Harold as a live dummy and even the coach is impressed by his unbroken spirit at the end of the day. To "reward" him, they make him water boy and let him think he's one of the substitutes.
![]() |
| Harold thinks his leg has broken apart, but it's the dummy's leg. |
![]() |
| Do you remember Pete from "Our Gang"? This is his dad, Pal the Wonder Dog, at six months old. He actually had a three quarter ring around his eye while Pete's ring was makeup. (Gundel wasn't sure you needed to know that. Always those dogs.) |
Harold hosts the "Fall Frolic" dance.
He gets a new suit for the occasion, but his tailor has dizzy spells and therefore can't make it in time, so the suit is only held together by basting stitches and finally falls apart.
From the phone booth he has hidden in, Harold sees how the Cad tries to force himself on Peggy and teaches him a lesson.
The Cad retaliates by telling him that he has never been popular and that it all has just been a big joke.
Harold is devastated, but Peggy comforts him and tells him to stop trying to be someone he isn't and make them like him for what he really is.
Harold sees his chance at the big football game still thinking he's in the team because Peggy who knows the truth didn't have the heart to tell him. When the coach runs out of substitutes because of injuries, he has to send in Harold to avoid the game being forfeited.
Of course, Harold manages a touchdown in the last minute - and with just one shoe on, too!
Sweeter to him than being celebrated by everyone, however, is this note that Peggy slips him while he's being carried into the locker room ...
Let me get something out of the way first.
I hate bullying of all sorts and I really felt for Harold. You are supposed to do that of course, but also still to be able to laugh. Therefore, the scene of him as a live tackle dummy is cut rather short and a scene at the ice cream parlor was actually cut completely according to Lloyd's autobiography because it made the test audience feel too sorry for Harold to be funny.
If you read my post about "Brown of Harvard", you may wonder why I even watched another college movie (by the way, it's said that "The Freshman" kicked off a college movie vogue).
The difference is that I knew bits of "The Freshman" from the olden days when I was still an innocent, fresh-faced kid. Seriously though, I did know parts from the old compilation films. This was Lloyd's financially most successful silent movie and I knew it would be hilarious.
Tom Brown annoys me, but I route for Harold even though they both end up in a big football game, a sport I know even less about than others.
Also Harold's football game is fun because he's still Harold. He's not athletic, he's struggling, and it's a miracle that he suceeds. Tom's isn't because he is a sportsman and we know that he just needs to shed off the old wisecracker's shell, get serious and do it. You know what I mean.
Something that I thought was funny, though - Lea Stans from "Silent-ology" also pointed it out - was that there was absolutely no mention of studying. Even Tom held a stack of books once even if not for long 😂
Then again one of the intertitles said: "Tate University - a large football stadium with a college attached." I wonder if that was the reason why the Germans literally called the movie "The sports student".
Most of all, however, Harold is relatable. He is the ordinary guy who wants to be popular, who wants to be liked, who wants to show what he can do. Probably we all have been there one way or the other, haven't we (I mean, isn't blogging and hoping for reactions a rather good example 😉)?
We can relate to his reaction when the Cad tells him the truth, the shock, trying to laugh it off like it's nothing, then the breakdown. And it's so sweet to see Peggy comforting him and building him up again. The chemistry between Harold and Peggy (Jobyna Ralston) is great.
Yes, and then it is just nice to see the ordinary guy succeed even if it's not very realistic and we know it. It's something we maybe hope for sometimes in our own lives.
"Wait a moment, though," I hear you say. "What was it you said about sports heros?"
The difference for me is that in the end you don't find Harold letting himself be celebrated in a crowd or a parade. You find him alone in the shower - which he turns on by accident without even noticing - with what's important to him. Peggy's note.
I love this movie and think it's really funny and sweet.
Sources and further reading:
1. Stephen Winer: The Freshman: Speedy Saves the Day! A Harold Lamb Adventure! On: The Criterion Collection. Essays, March 25, 2014
2. Lea Stans: Thoughts On: "The Freshman". On: Silent-ology, May 23, 2016
3. Harold Lloyd (in collaboration with Wesley W. Stout): An American Comedy, New York, NY, Dover Publ., republication of the 1928 edition


















































