First of all, let me say this post is just my personal opinion. I don't judge anyone for thinking differently or doing something differently, and while you are of course most welcome to share your own experience - in fact I'd love to hear it -, I ask you to return the courtesy.
Second, I'm obviously not a book blogger, just a reader and someone blogging without being very organized.
This post was inspired by a video YouTube recommended to me called "why i left goodreads for book journals".
I can't even say why I clicked on it as I'm neither on Goodreads nor keep a detailed book journal, but I got hooked because it made me think.
![]() |
| Picture via pxhere |
Short recap - I had always been an avid reader since my childhood, but when crafting came along, books went on the backburner because reading and crafting don't work at the same time (for those who are new, I can't do audiobooks). When crafting had to go on the backburner for several reasons, the books rushed back into my life like a big wave which I was very grateful for because the gap left had been big, too. In July 2025, I started posting lists of the books I had read each month (no reviews).
In November, I wrote "Again, this is not about numbers. Where do we stop if we rate reading by the number of books? Count pages? And next work out a formula which pages are "worth more" than others because some books are "only" children's books or light reading or scientific or profound ... I could keep going. Just enjoy!"
That's where the video comes in.
Vic explains how setting herself a goal for the year and checking reviews and ratings before but also after reading a book eventually made her feel like she was "losing a sense of identity and individuality with reading".
When she talked about reading goals, it made me wonder why I even numbered my list after saying it wasn't about numbers.
I know I didn't want to brag, but was I trying to prove something to myself? Did I feel I had to convince myself how well I had replaced crafting with reading? Did I need a number to show myself I filled the gap sufficiently and "productively"?
Or did I simply overthink this like usual and I numbered the list because that's what I do with lists?
Something else I hadn't consciously noticed before was that sometimes I felt a pang of guilt on a day without reading which is just ridiculous. Talk about self-inflicted pressure.
When I realized that, I happily binged a season of "The Great Pottery Throw Down" which always relaxes me (and my favorite potter won, too).
Recently, I have heard others say similar things - that they don't want to worry about reading what's popular or that they don't want to set themselves a number for the books they read. They want to enjoy what they read without pressure, pick what they feel like and when they feel like it.
That doesn't mean you can't read reviews anymore or have to dismiss all suggestions, but I think many people just don't want to get sucked in by the Internet and everyone's opinion as much anymore these days. Not just in regards to reading, but in general.
Vic's way to make her reading her own more again was to start a book journal.
That totally makes sense for people who enjoy that experience which can of course be so much more than just writing down titles. I'm just not the journaling type myself (and my handwriting has become so terrible) and know from experience I wouldn't keep it up for long. Who knows, though? Maybe the people I know who keep journals will inspire me eventually?
![]() |
| Picture via pxhere I chose one with old books because I love reading old books! |
So what did I take away for myself from this for now?
I'm not numbering my book lists anymore because it really isn't important.
I'll keep looking at suggestions and reviews on blogs of course and I'll happily discuss books with people I know, but I don't need to know what the whole world is thinking. I was fine without that before the Internet, I'll be fine now.
What I'm already doing is read what I want and not what I feel I should (although I sometimes feel guilty for not having read more German classics and I might try to catch up on that from time to time).
And believe it or not, I had a really hard time not numbering this last list! 😂






























